Rules Judge

Ask how a card or interaction works and get a straight answer, built from the Comprehensive Rules and the cards' official rulings, with every rule it relies on cited so you can read it yourself.

How the Rules Judge answers

Every question goes through the same steps. First the Judge works out which parts of the Comprehensive Rules the question touches: the keywords involved, the zones, timing, the stack, state-based actions, layers or the Commander rules. It then looks up every card you name on Scryfall and reads its Oracle text and Wizards' official rulings. Only that material is handed to the AI that writes the answer, and it is told to answer from it alone.

The answer is then checked before you see it. Every rule number it mentions has to exist in the Comprehensive Rules and has to be one of the rules it was given, and every card it marks as a card has to be one it looked up. If an answer fails those checks it is rewritten once, and if it still fails you get no answer rather than a guess. When the rules it found don't settle the question, it says so.

Questions it's good at

  • My 5/5 with trample and deathtouch is blocked by a 4/4. How much damage can I assign to the player?
  • My commander has a 'when this dies' ability. If I move it to the command zone, does the ability still trigger?
  • Can I respond to my opponent tapping Sol Ring for mana?
  • With Blood Moon out, does Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth still make every land a Swamp?
  • If I make a token copy of my commander, is the token a commander too?

Name cards exactly, or pick them with + Card, so the Judge reads the right Oracle text. It assumes a multiplayer Commander game unless you say otherwise. With + Deck you can ask about one of your saved analyses or a pasted list ("which of my creatures have flash?"), and every answer can be followed up.

What a question costs

Every account gets 3 free questions a day (a question about a deck counts as 2). After those, a question takes 1 credit, and a question about a deck 2 credits. Pro adds 75 credits a month. You are only charged for answers: off-topic questions, ones the rules don't settle and anything that fails its checks cost nothing, up to 10 of them a day; after that the Judge waits until the next day (UTC).

What it isn't

The Rules Judge is not an official judge and its answers are not official rulings. At a sanctioned event, call a judge: the event's judges decide. The Comprehensive Rules themselves are published by Wizards of the Coast at magic.wizards.com/en/rules, and the Judge is updated when a new version comes out. Your question, with the conversation's earlier questions and answers in a follow-up, is sent to Anthropic, which runs the AI, to write the answer, without your account; EDHcheck doesn't keep it unless you vote on the answer.

Related: AI deck builder·Combo finder·Card guessing game·Higher or lower·Game Changers·Mana base analysis