EDHcheck AI: A Deck Builder and a Rules Judge, Plus a Page for Every Card

EDHcheck AI builds a Commander deck for your commander, bracket and budget, from any card or your own collection, and answers rules questions with every rule cited. Plus card pages and top lists from over 136,000 decks, and every precon as a deck.

This is the biggest update EDHcheck has had. There are two new tools under EDHcheck AI: a Deck Builder that builds a full Commander deck around your commander, and a Rules Judge that answers rules questions and shows you the rules it used. Next to them, every card now has its own page with real statistics, there are top lists for cards and commanders, and every Commander precon opens as a deck.

Find EDHcheck AI in the Tools menu, or go straight to EDHcheck AI.

A deck for your commander, your bracket and your budget

Pick a commander, a bracket and, if you like, a budget, and the Deck Builder builds the other 99. It works with partners and Backgrounds too.

You choose where the cards come from:

  • Any card: the best cards for the deck, owned or not.
  • My collection first: the cards you own first, then the best ones to buy, within your budget.
  • Only my collection: a deck you can sleeve up tonight, every card from your collection.

You can also list cards it must play (up to 40) and cards it must leave out (up to 60), choose how strong the deck should be within its bracket, and write a few words about what you want: "lots of tokens", "no infinite combos", "make the opponents' creatures fight". The power setting is something the builder leans towards rather than a promise.

How it builds

The AI never picks cards from memory, because that's where AI deck builders go wrong: cards that don't exist, cards outside your colours, a "Bracket 2" deck with three Game Changers. EDHcheck does the groundwork first:

  1. Only cards your deck may play. Everything starts from cards legal in Commander, inside your commander's colour identity, and within your bracket the way EDHcheck's bracket rules count it: Game Changers, fast mana, extra turns, mass land denial and two-card combos.
  2. A ranked shortlist. Every one of those cards gets a score: how often players of your commander run it in decks analysed on EDHcheck, what your commander's own text makes and cares about, the jobs every deck needs done (ramp, card draw, removal, board wipes), the mana curve and the price.
  3. The AI chooses. EDHcheck AI picks the deck's spells from the top 400 of that list and writes the deck's plan. It can't play a card that isn't on the list.
  4. The mana base is worked out, not guessed. The builder sets the land count and colour sources the way EDHcheck's mana analysis asks for, and keeps to your budget at each card's cheapest printing.
  5. EDHcheck checks the deck. The finished list goes through the same analysis as any deck you paste in: bracket, power and combos. If it reads higher than the bracket you asked for, the builder takes out a card that pushes it up and checks again.

The deck lands in My Decks as a private draft. Every card is tagged with its job, the plan is in the deck's About tab, and you can see what the cards you don't own yet would cost. From there it's yours: swap cards, change the art, analyse it again, play it in the tester.

If the AI step doesn't finish, you get no deck and your credits come straight back. EDHcheck AI never hands you a deck it didn't build.

A Rules Judge that shows its work

Ask the Rules Judge how a card or an interaction works, and you get a straight answer built from the Comprehensive Rules and the cards' official rulings. Every rule it relies on is cited, so you can read it yourself.

It's good at the questions that come up at a real table:

  • My 5/5 with trample and deathtouch is blocked by a 4/4. How much damage can I assign to the player?
  • If I make a token copy of my commander, is the token a commander too?
  • With Blood Moon out, does Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth still make every land a Swamp?

Before you see an answer, EDHcheck checks it. Every rule number it mentions has to exist in the Comprehensive Rules and has to be one of the rules it was given, and every card it names has to be one it looked up. An answer that fails those checks is never shown, and you aren't charged for it.

Pick cards with + Card so the Judge reads the exact Oracle text, or use + Deck to ask about one of your saved analyses or a pasted list ("which of my creatures have protection from this?"). You can ask follow-ups, and it assumes a multiplayer Commander game unless you say otherwise. It uses the rules effective 6 November 2026, and gets new ones when Wizards publishes them.

Its answers aren't official rulings: at a sanctioned event, the event's judges decide.

Credits, and what's free

One balance pays for both tools.

  • Every account gets 3 free rules questions a day. A question about a deck counts as 2.
  • After the free ones, a rules question takes 1 credit, or 2 for a question about a deck. A deck build takes 10 credits.
  • Pro now includes 75 credits every month, enough for 7 deck builds. Unused credits carry over, up to 150.
  • Credit packs are coming soon, for any account, with or without Pro: 100 credits for $5 or 300 for $12. A pack's credits last 12 months, and you can withdraw from a pack within 14 days and get back what you haven't used.

You only pay for what works. A question that gets no answer (off-topic, not settled by the rules, or failing its checks) costs nothing, and neither does a build that doesn't finish. See pricing for the details.

A page for every card

Every card now has its own page at /cards/, with numbers from more than 136,000 decks analysed on EDHcheck. Open Sol Ring's page, for example, and you'll see:

  • how many decks play it, and what share of the decks that could play it do;
  • the brackets those decks are in;
  • the commanders that play it most, and the cards that go with it;
  • the combos it's part of, and public decks on EDHcheck that play it;
  • cheaper cards that do the same job, every printing and its price, and the card's rulings.

A commander's page adds its own decks: how many it leads, its signature cards (played far more under it than in other decks of its colours), the cards its decks play most, and a button to build one with EDHcheck AI.

Top lists

The top lists rank what Commander players actually play: the top cards and commanders, staples, and 15 more lists by type and job, from creatures and lands to ramp, removal, counterspells, tutors and Game Changers. Filter them by colours and bracket, and switch between the past 7, 30 or 90 days and all time.

Every precon, as a deck

All 183 Commander precons now open as decks. Pick a set on the precon pages, click a deck, and you get its list and bracket, with the full analysis one click away. Signed in, use Duplicate to my decks to start upgrading it in the deck builder. The set pages themselves have been rewritten from the decks' own lists and the cards' text.

Where the numbers come from

The card pages, top lists and the Deck Builder all count decks analysed on EDHcheck. Each one is kept as an anonymous record: its commander, its cards and our analysis, never your account, name or deck name, and no number from fewer than 10 decks is shown. If you'd rather your decks weren't counted, switch off Use the decks I analyse in EDHcheck's anonymous deck statistics in Settings.

Also new

  • Withdraw from contract here. A purchase made on the website can now be withdrawn from online, without emailing anyone: within 14 days of a new Pro subscription's first payment, or of buying a credit pack. The link is at the bottom of Settings, in the FAQ, on the pricing page and in the Terms.
  • Ask the Judge from anywhere. Card pages have an Ask the Rules Judge button and analyses an Ask the Judge button, which take the card or the deck along.

Try it at EDHcheck AI, and tell us what it gets right and wrong on Discord. Every report makes it better.

Comments

0 total

You need to sign in to comment.

Loading comments...